In West Bengal, West Bengal Police and Calcutta Police are almost worlds apart. They have separate Police Regulations, separate hierarchies and permeability only at the IPS level. I spent around three and half years in Calcutta Police as a Deputy Commissioner.
There is a vast stretch of vacant
land in front of Victoria Memorial which is called the Maidan. In 1756,
Siraj ud-Daulah had overrun the original Fort William, the English bastion
(located at the present GPO, Dalhousie Square). Learning from that lesson, Britishers
subsequently kept the area around the new Fort William vacant so that there was
clear line of fire, a tradition that continues to this day. No permanent
structure is allowed to come up in that area. Even the football clubs have
temporary stands. This is also the only breathing space in the crowded city so
people go there for morning walks, jogs, political rallies and just getting
together.
When I was Deputy Commissioner,
one day, a retired Chief Secretary, Mr. Gokul Dasgupta, had gone there for a
walk and, probably tired, sat down on a vacant bench. Immediately, two
Constables materialized and told him to get lost. When he tried to reason with
them, they told him that no one was allowed to sit on that particular bench and
that they were deployed just to prevent such a calamity. That would have been
the end of the matter but Mr. Dasgupta had been Chief Secretary of the state
and was very hurt (‘heart’ as we Calcuttans pronounce it). He called up the
Commissioner of Police to enquire why he could not sit on a vacant bench in a
vacant land which was open to public access. The Commissioner of Police asked
the Additional Commissioner of Police who asked the Joint Commissioner of
Police and so on down the line until it was verified that the concerned Police
Station, Hastings, had indeed detailed two policemen that day to prevent anyone
sitting on that bench. Since it was not clear why, the duty chart of the
Constables was checked. This is a chart which details the duty of each Constable
each day. It was found that every day, two constables were detailed for that
particular duty. The practice dated back to pre-Independence days. Apparently,
one day in the mists of time, that bench had been painted afresh and the local
police station was requested to detail two policemen to guard it till the paint
dried over. Since then, till that fateful accident of Mr. Dasgupta’s “heart”,
Calcutta Police had carried out the onerous duty every single day with
unflinching dedication, devotion and courage.
Just a few days after this
“incident”, I was visiting Victoria Memorial with my wife. After a stroll, we
sat down on a bench – a different one. Immediately, one guy in plainclothes
popped up demanding to know why I was doing such nongrami (bad behaviour). When
I couldn’t figure out what nongrami, he demanded to know why I was going around
with a female. I politely informed him that I had every right to go anywhere
with my wife. He further demanded to know what proof I had that she was my
wife. The conversation was rapidly escalating towards economics, i.e., demand
and supply of money when my security guard who was at a distance came running
and shouting at this chap in Hindi, “Tujhe pata nahin, kisse baat kar raha hai…”
Seeing my security guard, my tormentor promptly came to attention. I checked
where he was posted. It turned out that he was not even a cop. He had been a
Constable in Reserve Force of Calcutta Police but had been dismissed for such
activity. However, he had continued with the “activity.”
I also had the opportunity
(burden?) of performing election duty in a very sensitive constituency thrice.
This duty essentially involves going from booth to booth with a contingent of
force and checking against any disturbance or malpractice outside the booths.
(Police is not allowed inside the booth unless called by the Presiding
Officer.) Every round, I was asking what percentage of votes had been cast. It
was steadily going up – 10%, 12%, 15% and so on. By around 12.30, the poll
percentage was about 30% across the booths. I ordered that, barring a small
standby force, we should all have lunch and resume after half an hour. I
resumed patrolling at 1 PM and to my horror, in all the booths, the polling
percentage had dramatically climbed to 60 – 70 %. Not only had certain
political “managers” figured out by then exactly who all had not voted, they
had also monitored my movements and realized that that was the best window to
stuff the ballot boxes. No violence, no disturbance on the surface; just a “scientific
temper” and “dedicated” Presiding Officers.
The second time, I dispensed with
a general lunch break, made everyone eat dry food in the vehicles, and have non-stop
patrolling. At the end of a very tiring day, my officers and
I were sitting at the Police Station, congratulating each other on an
incident-free day of free and fair polling and awaiting the order to stand
down. One Inspector who resided in the area rang up his home to check regarding
voting by his family members and by the end of the phone call, his face fell.
His wife told him that she, along with 40 other families in the colony, had
gone to cast their votes but already some others had cast the votes in their
place.
The third time, we tried to guard
against these problems as best as we could. However, we had not accounted for
the advancing scientific temper of the political “managers.” At the end
of the day, we realized that, mysteriously, all the lifts in all the buildings
had gone out of order. The area is full of skyscrapers and naturally, a large
number of genuine voters in the higher floors could not come to vote. The
beauty of the scheme was that, in those pre-cell-phone, unconnected times,
every one thought that this was the case in his building only so there was no
complaint to the police or anyone. The poll percentage remained high at 70 %.
Since then, during every election in Calcutta, cops tended to be posted at the
lifts of many high-rises since the previous evening.
Calcutta is now Kolkata. Calcutta
Police is now Kolkata Police. May be, things are much different now.
[Names changed to protect identities]
That's a frightening view of democracy in action.
ReplyDeleteA win by an opposition party in an election is all the more creditable because their groundswell needs to outpace all these formidable handicaps.
DeleteAll eye-opening incidents for normal citizens … the one about freshly painted bench has possibly done rounds before …
ReplyDeleteHad posted this in our yahoogroup (much) earlier. Real life sometimes outdoes jokes. By the way, punkah pullers still existed and were recruited during my service career although hand-pulled punkahs had long disappeared...
DeleteThat incident of the secretary and the bench seems like something straight out of Yes Minister. I wonder what Sir Humphrey would say about that.
ReplyDeleteIt has been a joy discovering this blog. Wonderful !
Thank you. 🙏
Delete